 |
When
Max and Clara Fortunoff, Russian immigrants to the United States,
founded the 'pots a pans' business bearing their family name on
Livonia Avenue in Brooklyn, they could hardly have envisioned the
silver lining of the Fortunoff future sixty-seven years later. As
the early business grew to eight shops with hand painted signs hanging
from the ceilings and counters piled high with house and silver
wares accommodating the needs of a burgeoning neighbourhood, Max
and Clara's three children Lester, Marjorie and Alan joined the
family business distributing their respective skills in the specific
areas of their interests. Today, with five locations dotted around
New York State, including a 20,000 square foot, three level store
on Fifth Avenue, Fortunoff has come to be known as 'The Source'
for quality.
Whilst renowned
for their fine silver and flatware, the Fortunoff fortunes took
an added turn upwards, when Alan met and married a young woman from
his real estate appraisal class at New York University's business
Management School. Helen Fortunoff is now the head of the Fortunoff
fine jewellery division after having established this new facet
of the family retailing empire in 1957. "Max and Clara were
anxious to have the business expand as much as possible. They were
young people, very much alive when they handed us the reigns, but
they were very forward thinking people and they wanted to give their
children a sense of independence. My husband and I were just married
and we found ourselves in business", recalls Mrs. Fortunoff.
"Alan was attending Law School and at the time I was busy having
babies, so we decided that we would simply add to a business that
was already involved in fine silver and china, by bringing in the
dimension of fine jewellery.
"We went
into that area quite cold with no previous experience really coupled
with the fact that we were beginning in Brooklyn which was really
starting to change at that time. We were very fortunate in that
we met several influential people from Long Island, including the
then owner of the property that we are now in. Business really began
to boom when we moved to Long Island. We were an immediate success
in this location. It was a very unique store for the area; the merchandise
that we offered was very upscale and we provided a very broad selection.
It really was a 'happening'".
Over her thirty-seven
year career, Helene has been a pioneer in fine jewellery
in the United
States, accruing countless accolades which applaud her acute business
sense and forge a solid road for women in the jewellery industry
in the process. She was the first woman member of the elite DeBeers
group, The United States Carat Club, in addition to her ongoing
commitments to the executive committees of the Jewellers of America,
the Jewellery Industry Council and The Society of Jewellery Historians
USA. She is a sought after public speaker and a tireless community
worker as well as being a proud mother of six, several of whom are
already active in the business thus carrying Fortunoff into a third
generation of retailers.
Amongst the
lofty echelons of Fifth Avenue jewellers, Fortunoff holds a particular
appeal that can perhaps be best characterised by the personality
of Helene Fortunoff. Warm and vibrant, like its principal-in-charge,
the fine jewellery boutiques at Fortunoff display diamonds at many
tens of thousands of dollars, but they are most likely to be purchased
by the unassuming CEO "whose face one would not have seen in
the newspaper", or by the "successful working career woman,
making a purchase for herself". The family atmosphere at Fortunoff
- the constant hive of activity and the fact their customers are
not looking for rarefied air, implies a relaxed feeling that Helene
actively encourages.
VIVE spoke with
Mrs. Fortunoff in the Long Island store about the fortunes of an
American retailing institution...
VIVE: How would
you compare the American and European markets in terms of jewellery?
FORTUNOFF: I
think that it is a very different mentality, they are very greatly
stratified there. In other words you have a customer who is only
in the very, very upper echelons of merchandise, she is looking
for very expensive products and then you have a big chasm where
it simply drops down enormously in quality. There is a middle class
of jewellery consumer there of course, but somehow the jewellery
doesn't seem to be appealing to it. In Italy where you have, let
us say, an 'investment mentality', where every woman wants to have
her gold chains and bracelets, that is a different case altogether.
I think that in the States a woman is considerably more fashion
oriented in that she wants to have a beautiful pair of earrings:
she could be a person who earns a very nominal salary but when she
goes out she wants fashion and because of that she is a repeat customer.
I will say that in Europe, quality tends to be the paramount consideration
when they make their selection and in the States perhaps that is
not always necessarily the case: they frequently want a lighter
item or they want an item that is larger and more fashionable, but
I think that n the whole you have a certain joie de vivre when it
comes to the acquiring of jewellery here.
VIVE: Whom do
you feel is leading the way in terms of jewellery design today?
FORTUNOFF: I
have a particular theory from a manufacturer's point of view that
the French have the germ of the idea, the German's build it like
a brick fortress and the Italians make thirty variations of the
French item and really bring it to the marketplace. That is my own
perception of the jewellery circle.
I don't think
that the French are necessarily the leaders still because I feel
that there is a narrowness in the design perspective; they are not
as open to all of the various impetus. I would say that the Italians
today are much more adventurous; certainly there are so many more
companies and there is an enormous sense of family pride in the
Italian manufacturing scene and I feel that they are much more receptive
to change. The French make extraordinarily beautiful merchandise
and I think a lot of it is very innovative but what I am saying
is that they have very narrow lines and they appeal to only a certain
segment of the population. The fact that Italian people themselves
are acquirers of gold jewellery has led to a tremendous amount of
development in their own right.
VIVE: How would
you characterise American design skills by comparison?
FORTUNOFF: There
are many wonderful American jewellery designers. I would say that
we are seeing a renaissance of beautiful design from the young,
talented designers today who are completely innovative, very forward
thinking, and from them I see a complete metamorphosis. I now see
for the first time, Italy copying from the States. We have a young
man named Charles Krypell who designs jewellery for us that is very
sophisticated, very architectural and I think that that sort of
style has been developed here in the States. Jose Hess also, is
a wonderful jewellery designer - very fluid, sensual, heavily into
diamonds. Henry Dunay is different again, his work I would say is
a little more architectural again, however, he has several unique
specialities such as the way in which he works his gold and in many
cases I feel that he is emulated by many people in the States. Robert
Lee Moris represents a stable of very young designers. I think their
work is modern, it appeals to a 'young artistic' crowd to a different
clientele, but in many cases it is much warmer than the innovative
Germanic look which is hard at times, almost grotesque. It is to
hard for most people to wear and as such does not appeal to a broad
spectrum of people. But a lot of the new designers have managed
to retain the element of warmth - you still have a great line, you
still have new stones, new faceting, a lot of experimentation and
I think that today this is very much the American niche. We are
carrying many young design people and one of my 'pets' again is
to nurture young people. Secretly, I know that when I place an order
it perhaps won't sell as quickly as one would like, but I want them
to have the encouragement and the market place, I want them to have
the exposure in a Fifth Avenue environment just to see how the customer
will react to new looks. I know that in many cases, I have written
the first order that they have ever had and I feel a pleasure in
that.
VIVE: How do
you find doing business in New York given the vast representation
of people from such a wide cross-section of both American and international
society?
FORTUNOFF: I
think that first of all, by virtue of where our store is situated
it is frequently like a bazaar. We get representatives from the
United Nations coming in saying, 'Quick, I need a dinner service
for thirty, for an important diplomatic function tonight!' They
tend not to have it as readily available at their respective embassies
as you might think so they come in to buy it from us as needed.
There is a well-known businessman who came in with his fiancee and
his bodyguard of all things, just prior to their costume engagement
party. He stayed so long - after having bought $US90,000 worth of
assorted jewellery, that after he had finished, he put on his costume
in the store to go to his party and he insisted that the Floor Manager
put on a costume and come as well! In the New York store we serve
many celebrities, rock stars...In the Long Island store where I
spend most of the time Barbara Streisand came in looking very simple
and as unobtrusive as possible. This happens a good deal because
we are close to Estbury Music Fair where many entertainers gather.
Most of them do not want to be recognised, they want to come in,
just shop and to be treated 'regularly'. On Fifth Avenue, this happens
all the time. They just want to get in and out, as painlessly as
possible and I would say that we go out of our way to accommodate
that.
VIVE: What is
the most expensive item you have sold?
FORTUNOFF: That
would probably be a single diamond solitaire, costing about US$500,000,
sold to just a successful businessman - not anyone that you would
recognise off the streets. Ordinary success...
VIVE: What were
some of the important lessons that you learned from your early years
in business in the Bronx?
FORTUNOFF: As
a young businesswoman, I learned some very valuable lessons regarding
how to communicate with the public. I will never forget my very
first pearl sale back in Brooklyn when a little old lady came in
to the store wearing a house-dress. Normally, I suppose that many
people would not have bothered with her very much because she looked
so poor. As an owner - I don't like anyone to go unattended - I
went over to her to see if she needed any assistance and she bought
a string of cultured pearls for $500 which thirty years ago was
not a little price. Everyone was astounded that she could afford
them - maybe she had saved for this purchase for many years, I don't
know, but you must remember that it was this sort of neighbourhood.
That was a very good lesson which I have tried to instill in all
of my staff - that they should approach everyone as if they have
a million dollars in their pocket and not to pigeonhole anyone.
We test them in this area too: we have a special service in the
States that caters for this. 'Customers' come in giving all sorts
of problems, demanding refunds, they ask technical questions and
the staff's responses are all written up and placed in their files.
VIVE: What would
your advice be to someone today, who wants to be sitting in your
seat?
FORTUNOFF: I
think that my advice would be to be completely unafraid; not to
be afraid to make mistakes, to be extremely open to change and challenge.
The environment today presents these elements and the one thing
to ensure is that you retain your humility, don't believe your own
P.R., and not to be afraid if you are doing something that is different
to the rules. When I began in the business, I was often told not
to do my displays in a certain way because they were different from
the conventional manner. We display on three levels whereas I was
told initially that jewellery showcases should only be on one level,
but I had so much merchandise and so little space that I had to
stack on three levels. I designed trays that held twenty pairs of
earrings because nobody was making them. I didn't know that it wasn't
the 'right' thing to do, I simply did it. I would say that that
should be the rule today - develop your own methods, your own strategies....don't
be afraid.
VIVE: Who are
the people that really fascinate you in business today?
FORTUNOFF: You'll
kill me when I say this, but I would have to say that it is my husband.
He is the most extraordinary businessman that I have ever met: I
think that he is an advertising genius and I have complete regard
for both himself and his ethics. Apart from that, I would say that
when I worked with Lauren Bacaul - she did some advertisements for
us years ago - I certainly enjoyed it. She is a very 'salty' woman
- she does not compromise, has strong beliefs and strong standards
and she is an independent human being, her own person.
VIVE: Where
do you think America is going in your opinion?
FORTUNOFF: That
is a very good question. I want to be positive but I see too much
polarisation. As a person who hopes for homogenisation, I see instead
too much divergence between the people who live a very difficult
existence and those who have the pleasure of a luxurious, leisurely
lifestyle. So, I see an enormous split and I am concerned by it....
VIVE: Isn't
this the country where you can be one or the other?
FORTUNOFF: Certainly
I would say that I am delighted by the success stories of many of
the new cultures that have come to the United States and so I see
from that point of view, that there is a lot of what I call 'infusion'
of small business, a tremendous vitality as far as that goes. But,
I also worry about that lower economic strata of our society who
I think are rapidly becoming desperate because they are being over-looked.
I think that there are tremendous opportunities still in the United
States for people who have imagination and ambition and who are
not afraid to work hard.
VIVE: What are
some of the aspects of the jewellery industry that you particularly
enjoy?
FORTUNOFF: I
tend to be very lucky in that I travel all over the world and I
am given the opportunity to meet with some very interesting people.
When I went to Israel, I got to dance with the Minister of Commerce
who invited me to do a passe double. I had never done one in my
life and he simply got up and did it this most difficult step beautifully.
This was a white haired gentleman who's sitting at this very official
dinner. I was a leader of the first jewellery fair that was held
in Israel, and as the leader of the American group, the biggest
delegation, I was put next to the most important officials. Interestingly
enough, I never thought that [the Minister] would remember me, but
I was in Israel about twelve years later, in 1982, dining in a wonderful
restaurant and the Minister walked in and came right over to my
table and chatted.
In India, where
I go to purchase diamonds, I have been to weddings between people
in the diamond business. They are arranged marriages where one spends
three or four days in celebration, and one experiences the whole
ritual which is quite extraordinary. a particular wedding was the
first time, in fact that I had met some of the top people in the
CSO.
VIVE: Do you
do much business with Israel?
FORTUNOFF: We
do a lot of business there; being a very big diamond capital we
go there for many of our diamonds. The industry is constantly growing
there and producing a fine quality. The rough comes by way of the
Central Selling Organisation (CSO), buying from Antwerp. Within
Israel itself, they have a very large cutting operation. I was very
fortunate in that as I was the leader of the first delegation, they
treated me very specially there and I made a lot of friends that
were permanent. When my daughter went there she used to do her laundry
at the house of the President of the Board! They are very aggressive
in their diamond dealings, but I have admiration for them because
they are under such stress there and I like the Israelis much more
than most tend to, I suppose.
VIVE: The diamond
industry seems to be a very close knit society, rather like a brotherhood.
Has it been very difficult for a woman to penetrate it?
FORTUNOFF: I
consider myself to be extremely lucky in this industry because I
was the first woman for many, many things, and even now I would
say that I probably have the most visibility of any woman in the
industry in the United States. I don't know whether that is a good
or a bad thing. I simply have a high profile because I am very active
amongst executive committees. I like this sort of thing, I speak
a good deal publicly, and I am very controversial about it. Because
I harangue the manufacturers a great deal about quality and about
design, I tend to be very outspoken, very blunt and I am pretty
well known for that within the industry.
I was the first
woman to become a member of the Carat Club in the United States,
a private group sponsored by DeBeers made up of prominent retailers
from all over the U.S. who are not allowed to meet in this country
but gather at many places elsewhere around the world to meet with
international members of the industry. At my first meeting in Banff,
Canada, I had the pleasure of meeting Anthony Oppenheimer, of the
DeBeers CSO board. He was to give the opening talk on the state
of the diamond economy so, on the plane over, I honed up on all
the facts; I knew the productivity and production ration of all
the mines in South Africa, all sorts of statistics - I wanted so
much to be knowledgeable being the first woman member. After he
had given the talk, he asked if there were any questions. Now everyone
is very awed by Mr. Oppenheimer and very careful about what they
say, and as I sat there, I knew that I had a question that I wished
to ask. I tentatively raised my hand, asked my question but I did
not think that he had given me a full enough answer. I was probing,
so I asked him again, rephrasing my question, and I began to push
at him - he didn't wish to make a big deal about the question but
I doggedly wanted to know, and as I asked the second time, all of
a sudden, a member of their group, very gently nudged my knee and
said, 'I have arranged for you to speak to Mr. Oppenheimer privately,
don't pursue it now'. I immediately stopped. After the break, they
reshuffled the seating and I was put next to Mr. Oppenheimer for
the duration of the conference. He had a dossier on everybody, he
knew everything, although he was very discreet. We got along very
well, and after my last trip, when I was in Glen Eagle, Scotland,
I took my first tour of Charter House street where the DeBeers operation
is located. I had the privilege of being asked to the private dining
room upstairs to lunch with the Chairman of Anglo-American - the
gold company, and Oppenheimer. He kept pumping me for information
about business operations in the States and I was so conscious of
giving correct, interesting answers that I could feel the perspiration
dripping down my face!
VIVE: What sort
of relationship do you have now with these people?
FORTUNOFF: Let
me say that that entire group is entirely fascinating: you don't
have a conversation with them, they grill you, anyone and everyone
- they are really tough cookies! I would say that my relationship
with them is not as close as it is with the manufacturers. My husband
does not get involved with the jewellery at all, although he does
tend to check up on me! Firstly, I have made a lot of friends within
the industry, travelling a lot by myself, we have had many escapades.
I have loved to dance since I was small, and I used to go to the
discotheques when I was a bit younger on my trips to Basel. I used
to make many of the manufacturers take me dancing to this awfully
sleazy disco there called 'Hazyland'. My husband would call at 11.00
p.m. having assumed that I had had a delicious business dinner and
was safely in my room by 10.00 p.m. when really I was out discoing
at Hazyland! He knows not to call now. I don't do it any more, of
course, but I suppose I used to have quite a reputation amongst
the American manufacturers!
VIVE: With the
family tradition being so historically strong at Fortunoff, have
you the same sort of ambitions for your children?
FORTUNOFF: Well,
besides my daughter who is now our diamond buyer, my son Louis,
is also involved in the business. An indication of his ability is
that he is Head of Personnel: He is really great, very bright and
well-educated. I am the sort of parent that insisted that my children
work - it was never something that was decided upon themselves -
in my family, you had to work. My children started work around me
when they were nine or ten years old, they might scotch tape boxes
or whatever. Louis would sell cutlery; a customer might come up
and there is this little ten year old boy, dressed in a suit, and
trying to do a good job selling cutlery. A man came up to him once
and said; 'What are you doing here? Don't you realise that there
are child labour laws? Louis argued back and forth with him and
finally told him it was his job, that he belonged here, he was the
owner's son and he could sell very well thank-you very much! My
children did not get allowances, they earned their livings. My daughter,
who is now active with the diamonds became a buyer when she was
14 - I had to know where she was in the afternoons - she was a wild
child! She began to buy at that age, she would see salesmen and
choose merchandise when they came here, and she would go to the
trade shows. She didn't understand the technicalities of diamond
grading until she was in her thirties but she grew up around the
procedures. We began taking our children on business trips abroad
when they were in High School. Normally they would come to France
or Italy with us when they were 12 or so and attend the showings
with us and then as their vacations permitted they would travel
more extensively with us.
I also have
children who don't necessarily live the same lifestyle as we do.
One of my daughters lives on a farm in Oregon, drives a pick-up
truck, raises her own vegetables, is a potter who built her own
kiln and is very much into a holistic style of living. My children
are quite diverse; another of my daughters is an architect, another
daughter at Sotheby's and is about to come into the family business,
so that will make a third. I have a fourth son, who is being trained
now. I love working with my children: I would say that if there
is a special pleasure that I take in business, it would be working
with my children and watching them assume authority, and feeling
assured knowing that they will take care of business without me
having to check up. I know that it will be done properly. I love
watching them grow and seeing them be successful.
|
|