|
The Australian
sapphire industry is preparing a new, assertive strategy to establish
its own reputation in the world gemstone market - a reflection of
Australia's growing maturity as a producer of international quality.
Heiress apparent
to her effervescent sister the diamond, sapphire has a mysterious,
almost mythological attraction - drawing the eye in to their rich
iridescent centres, they entice with a promise of hypnotic discovery.
We know the diamond well, her sheer blinding brilliance is familiar
to the many who have wooed her, but we hover uncertainly two steps
away from the enigmatic sapphire, hesitantly awaiting an introduction
to this dark lunar lady.
Sapphire has
enjoyed multifarious often strangely incongruous uses throughout
her history; form being crushed and powdered as medicine, acting
as an auspicious business card for the benefit of wealthy French
noblemen, to an exotic elixir administered to less than amourous
lovers. Sapphire has lived for many years in relative obscurity
far away from notoriety in the outback mines of rural Australia.
Few would be aware that some of the world's most shining examples
of sapphire have been leaving the enclaves of the wide brown land
to be sold on the world markets as anything but prize Australian
yield. It is not surprising then that Australia herself has been
slow to recognise the potential gains of an indigenous sapphire
industry.
Gerry Yakoumelis'
father knew nothing about sapphires when he established his mixed
business in the New South Wales mining town of Inverell in the late
1950's. In fact he would have preferred the cash to the jars of
sapphire Crystal tendered to him by the miner's in lieu. Not knowing
exactly what it was that he should do with his glittering booty
he opted to stockpile it away over several years in three 44 gallon
drums at the rear of his shop.
"He had
heard of sapphires in much the same way that everyone has",
says Gerry of G. & J. Sapphire Merchants. "But he was certainly
not familiar with grading the quality or the value. To him they
just looked like little blue pebbles.
"At this
time, Inverell was just beginning to establish its reputation as
a source of sapphires and a few tourists were starting to pass through
the town just to see where Australian sapphires were sourced. My
father would put together a small parcel of a few pieces and give
them to the tourists as incentive for them to buy things from the
shop, but even if they didn't he was happy to give them away anyway".
Mr. Yakoumelis'
fortunes changed the day that a Swiss Gem dealer arrived in Inverell
to investigate the rumours abounding worldwide throughout the industry
that Australia was host to a plethora of the rough material. Unsure
of where he was to begin in his search, the dealer ended an exhausting
bout of fruitless enquiries with a cup of coffee in Mr. Yakoumelis'
store. In passing, he asked where he could purchase rough sapphire,
whereupon Gerry's father led him to the drums in the back of the
shop.
"The dealer
sat down and selected a handful of the top quality gem sapphire
and the money that my father received from this simple transaction
compensated for a whole year of no cash/barter agreements"
says Gerry, "But still this was only one man and he seldom
came to purchase the stones, so at this stage I would say that it
was very much a cottage industry. It took my father about five years
to realise the potential of this business but he didn't have any
connections apart from the errant Swiss dealer. Eventually one thing
led to another and an Englishman approached him on the same basis
purchasing a few samples at first and then slowly building up. It
wasn't until 1968 that the real buyers started coming".
The history
of the sapphire industry in Australia as a whole is an intermittent
and colourful as Mr. Yakoumelis' own experience, the latter in fact
making an effective allegory with the universal development. Rough
sapphire was detected as early as the 1890's in Anakie in Queensland
and in 1854 in the New England areas and small scale mining operations
there supplied the world with a limited amount of the gems. The
fortunes of World War I and the incumbent instability of European
politics halted any possibility of development and mining for sapphires
did not resume until the early 1960's as an unprecedented demand
for rough sapphire turned buyer's eyes towards Australian fields.
Strongly represented amongst those searching for the Australian
jewel were the Thai's whose influence has dominated the fortunes
of the Australian industry ever since.
"Thai buyers
initially came to Australia at the request of Eastern Gems which
was the first company in Australia to start buying mining and marketing
sapphire on a large scale", says Gerry. "Commencing operations
in 1964, the company achieved during its years of business, an average
annual turnover of $2 million. Today they could have been the Debeers
of sapphires had they not encountered crippling financial problems.
Their difficulties began when large scale mechanical mining increased
causing a flood of sapphires on the market, dropping the price by
an incredible 95%. Limited by insufficient funds to continue buying
all the production from New England and Queensland sapphire areas,
Eastern gems invited their Thai customers to Australia to buy directly
from the mines for a commission on the purchases, in a bid to salvage
the business.
"The Thai
buyers, having been introduced to the miners, no longer needed to
buy sapphires from Eastern Gems and the company went into receivership.
Additionally, the Thai buyers purchased all of the miners' production
- from low grade right up to the top gem quality stones. I am of
the opinion that had the financial backers fully understood the
mechanisms of the gem business instead of failing to provide Eastern
Gems with the funds necessary to continue purchasing, there could
have been a substantial sapphire industry in Australia today".
"The creme
de la creme is the Kashmire sapphire or the Burmese stone -
they certainly command the highest prices", says Brenton Dalheimer,
a seventh generation cutter of Mineral in Australia. "The next
step down in order of ranking, you have the very good quality Sri
Lankan sapphire and then you have the very good quality Australian
sapphire which is not necessarily sold in Bangkok as Australian.
It really does have a beautiful blue - it commands, say, US $5-6,000
per carat so it isn't a cheap stone by any means". Trying to
introduce the top quality Australian stones to the market as just
that, 'Australian sapphires', is going to prove a difficult task.
"When the
Thai buyers sell stones purchased in Australia to the European markets,
they are never sold as Australian", explains Gerry. "They
sell the high quality merchandise as Thai, the better quality as
Sri Lankan and the even better as Burmese. So when the buyer goes
to Bangkok to buy a parcel of say, 100 pieces of sapphire and this
parcel is said to be from Sri Lanka, 80 pieces may be from there
but 20 pieces could well be Australian. So it is really quite difficult
to try to project an image for Australian sapphires as being top
quality because there has been fifty years of this continual umbrella
marketing and similarly declaring that Australian sapphires are
always dark and not of desired quality.
"What we
are trying to do is to promote the top end of Australian sapphires
- openly voicing that Australia does produce some of the best sapphires
in the world. They can compare and compete with the Sri Lankan and
even the Burmese and the price is nowhere near what you would pay
for the latter".
It has now been
established that the desirability of Australian sapphire lies in
its uniformity of colour, but as the fledgling Australian industry
rested increasingly on the Thai's and their directives, the luckless
process of trial and error became the method by which Mr. Yakoumelis
Snr. was initiated.
"Possibly
my father's biggest mistake during the very difficult 1968-75 period
was in not travelling overseas to find real, consistent buyers and
in not investigating the real value of sapphires. He didn't even
know that Thailand was the major cutting country - there was no-one
there to teach him properly, he had very limited information and
had to glean what he could from others and nine times out of ten
it was the wrong information anyway.
"My father
started working for a Thai as a buyer. He would give my father $10,000
and then come over at the end of the month to pick up the parcel,
take it back to Thailand, process it and return with $20,000. It
would continue to double up each month and my father would get a
commission from it so that in effect he was trying to glean someone
else's knowledge, but it wasn't valid information - they'd always
steer everyone the wrong way. For instance, they would say that
the big, blue, dark sapphires were the best when in fact the clear,
light blue stones were preferable, so they would pay nothing for
the top quality and everyone else was left with the wrong conception
of value. My father began to buy up small parcels with his commission
and then sell them to other merchants but of course he was unknowingly
buying up the wrong ones. After a few years he had a huge parcel
of these large, black stones that he had to try to move. It was
a situation of the ball being in their court all the time and they
taking advantage of it.
"My father
finally realised the discrepancies when he would present his parcels
to other merchants and they consistently chose the lighter stones.
You have to buy everything that the miners show you because they
don't just want to sell the top end, so you take the good with the
bad and really that was a good way for my father to work out what
people really wanted. He presented a mixed parcel, they made their
selections and he got a rough idea of the market demand and the
best prices. When he finally went to Thailand at the request of
his Thai boss, he was shown a vastly pared down version of the mechanisms
of the industry and he also took some of his own stones to have
cut which were exchanged and an inferior stone was returned to him.
"He first
encountered the heat treating process at this time in which inclusions
or any silt is cleared from the stone by virtue of a heating process
and the stone is made lighter. Today the process involves placing
the stones in a very high temperature electric furnace, although
in Thailand they still use the older methods whereby the stones
are placed in a crucible and then transferred to a coke furnace
with an airblower underneath, creating temperatures of about 1500-16000C.
Then, the Thai's claimed that the stones were often unavoidably
burned and broken which is untrue and they would give back little
pieces instead of the original large stone. They really did not
want anyone else to learn about the processes and this is why there
is such a 'real' sapphire industry in Thailand: they really knew
their business".
Mr. Yakoumelis
Snr. left the employ of the Thai merchant but agreed to look after
the man's son who was to arrive in Australia. As a gesture of appreciation,
the son taught him the correct heat treatment methods and basically
set the record straight, consolidating his knowledge and pointing
Mr. Yakoumelis in the right direction. His own skills had developed
after his 12 years in the business to the point where he could grab
a handful of stones at random and correctly declare their weight
by virtue of his trained eye and experience, a trick that held him
in good stead with the fastidious European buyers whom he had wooed,
won and who had introduced him to the true top quality in 1973.
Business began
to grow at a rapid and steady pace and the Yakoumelis' moved to
Sydney with Gerry's father travelling to Inverell each week to scout
parcels, returning them to Sydney for sorting, preparations for
orders and shipping out. "Things were going very well at this
time", says Gerry, "orders were coming in regularly, there
was a good continuity of supply, business was growing at a very
nice pace, rather than booming: it didn't just shoot up overnight
- my father is an extremely cautious man....
"Then in
late 1979 to the early eighties, the supply began to slowly dwindle.
The biggest mines began to pull out and stop mining due to the lack
of stones - it had virtually dried up. We had orders but little
supply inasmuch as we could fill existing orders but not enough
to search for new customers and that is when things really began
to deteriorate, becoming very difficult in 1984. Even now, although
the situation is improving, the supply is very small in comparison
with our orders, so I have begun to process stones which is a higher
risk in that stocks must be held onto longer but there is a greater
return in the long term that makes it worthwhile".
"The dealer
sat down and selected a handful of the top quality gem sapphires
and the money that my father received from this simple transaction
compensated for a whole year of no cash/barter agreements",
says Gerry, "But still this was only one man and he seldom
came to purchase the stones, so at this stage I would say that it
was very much a cottage industry. It took my father about five years
to realise the potential of this business but he didn't have any
connections apart from the errant Swiss dealer. Eventually one thing
led to another and an Englishman approached him on the same basis
purchasing a few samples at first and then slowly building up. It
wasn't until 1968 that the real buyers started coming".
The history
of the sapphire industry in Australia as a whole is as intermittent
and colourful as Mr. Yakoumelis' own experience, the latter in fact
making an effective allegory with the universal development. rough
sapphire was detected as early as the 1890's in Anakie in Queensland
and in 1854 in the New England areas and small scale mining operations
there supplied the world with a limited amount of the gems. The
fortunes of World War I and the incumbent instability of European
politics halted any possibility of development and mining for sapphires
did not resume until the early 1960's as an unprecedented demand
for rough sapphire turned buyers' eyes towards Australian fields.
Strongly represented amongst those searching for the Australian
jewel were the Thai's whose influence has dominated the fortunes
of the Australian industry ever since.
"Thai buyers
initially came to Australia at the request of Eastern Gems which
was the first company in Australia to start buying, mining and marketing
sapphire on a large scale", says Gerry. "Commencing operations
in 1964, the company achieved during its years of business, an average
annual turnover of $2 Million. Today they could have been the Debeers
of sapphires had they not encountered crippling financial problems.
Their difficulties began when large scale mechanical mining increased
causing a flood of sapphires on the market, dropping the price by
an incredible 95%. Limited by insufficient funds to continue buying
all the production from New England and Queensland sapphire areas,
Eastern Gems invited their Thai customers to Australia to buy directly
from the mines for a commission on the purchases, in a bid to salvage
the business.
"The Thai
buyers, having been introduced to the miners, no longer needed to
buy sapphires from Eastern Gems and the company went into receivership.
Additionally, the Thai buyers purchased all of the miners' production
- from low grade right up to the top gem quality stones. I am of
the opinion that had the financial backers fully understood the
mechanisms of the gem business instead of failing to provide Eastern
Gems with the funds necessary to continue purchasing, there could
have been a substantial sapphire industry in Australia today".
The lack of
centralised cohesion within the Australian industry coupled with
international influences, their market demands and buyers and the
contrived falsehood that Australian gems are never premium grade
quality, have meant that Australia has long been a player on the
bench in the global sapphire game. For many years Australian sapphire
has been marketed overseas as low or commercial grade quality whilst
Australia's top grade gems have been marketed as Burmese, Sri Lankan
or Thai when in actual fact it has been estimated that Australia
produces as much as 70% of the world's total volume of sapphire
with the top grade merchandise comparable to the world's best. Sapphires
are not exclusively blue, contrary to popular belief, although the
blue shade is the most expensive with the finest examples coming
from Kashmir. Sapphires can be seen in yellow, pink, violet and
green and a combination of different colours in sapphire is known
as 'parti-colours' of which Australia produces some of the most
beautiful in the world.
The manner in
which sapphires are formed in nature depends very much on the location
of the deposits. In Kashmir, Burma and in all likelihood, Sri Lanka,
they were formed by a metamorphosis of limestone that contained
aluminium oxide impurities and other trace elements for colouring.
The Mines Department in Australia has established a new theory although
as yet unvalidated that Australian sapphires were formed deep in
the earth's crust prior to erupting to the surface. If proved correct,
this knowledge would be invaluable in pinpointing previously unexploited
areas of deposits.
The colour of
sapphires is obtained by impurities - pure sapphire being colourless,
blue sapphire coloured by impurities including titanium and iron.
A sapphire crystal in its purest form is aluminium oxide and hexagonal
in shape, occasionally pointed at both sides like a diamond.
In judging the
quality of a good sapphire, the most important element is its colour,
irrespective of whether there are slight inclusions or faults inside.
If the colour is uniformly good, this will determine its value.
Following colour, clarity, cut and brilliance are important considerations.
"In trying
to find a good sapphire, I look for a blue which stands out",
says Gerry. "I look at it in different lights - in natural
and artificial light and in darker areas. I will often place it
in areas with lots of shadow, perhaps under a table. If the blue
is still prominent and has a glowing effect or lustre then I concede
that it is a good stone. If the stone tends to be a bit darker in
the shadow or good only in natural light and poor in artificial,
then that detracts from the value".
Gerry opted
to enter the family business and studied gemology extensively in
the United States and in Australia to complement his practical knowledge
whilst working for a South African diamond firm with whom his father
was affiliated. He established his own business, G. & J. Gem
Merchants with his brother in 1984 which sees both facets of the
sapphire industry accommodated by the appropriate Yakoumelis - Gerry
looking after the cut stones side of the business and his father
concentrating on the rough stones. An avid understanding of each
other's roles and capacities ensures that Gerry has a strong knowledge
of the rough which he feels is invaluable in his side of the business.
Faced with the
decrease of supply, Gerry was forced to make a decision as to the
orientation of his company and therein lies the dilemma of the Australian
industry - whether the emphasis should be placed on rough stones
or whether Australia should actively pursue a competitive foray
into full scale cutting and processing.
"We had
two options, to diversify into other gems or to look for other sources
of sapphire - by other sources I mean other countries which were
already producing rough sapphire, "says Gerry". At about
this time, the New South Wales Department of Mineral Resources placed
a reserve over the entire New England area for what was to be the
first ever granting of exploration licences. This came after a four
year study by the department as to the source of sapphire. Now we
had a third option - to stay in Australia and explore for and hopefully
mine sapphire. Our experience is neither in exploration nor mining
but we have decided to take this new path with high risk but hopefully
with more potential reward. We would not have to rely on the supply
of rough from an outside source.
"When the
Department called for Expressions of Interest we applied for the
whole area. From the 23 sectioned off areas we were successful in
securing 19 of which we have since dropped three because we felt
that there was insufficient deposits to warrant securing the necessary
separate mining license and additionally, the whole operation is
an extremely expensive exercise. The reason the government allocated
us so much of the area is due to the longevity of my father in the
business and the fact that he was one of the few Australian exporters
when most were selling to the Thai's so that they could export.
It really wasn't an Australian industry in this sense, so the government
was trying to promote one. We have developed a twelve year strategy
to encompass other aspects of the trade, but I believe that it is
not to anyone's advantage to rush into territory that is new to
them, although the learning period is long and costly.
"It is
our dream to see a more closely integrated sapphire industry in
Australia and to achieve this we need greater control by producers,
without them having to rely on the Thai's as their only source of
income. It implies greater co-operation and support between the
gem dealers and the miners and it also means that more processing
would have to be done by local dealers".
This is a plan
avidly supported by Brenton Dalheimer who feels that mining licenses
should only be issued to people like the Yakoumelis' who have a
genuine interest in doing the cutting and polishing processes in
Australia, although the Department of Minerals and Resources does
not yet have the legislative authority to declare such a condition.
"The biggest
problem that we have in Australia is that there is no aprenticeship
scheme for cutters and polishers like they have in Germany where
there is a particular town that is basically a gemstone cutting
training centre for the rest of the world. It has been established
for hundreds of years and they have a fully integrated training
scheme whereby people go through a three year period and finish
up as qualified cutters. My grandfather in fact was trained there",
says Brenton.
"When you
are dealing with expensive qualities of sapphire, the important
element is to retain as much of the weight from the rough as possible.
The general rule of thumb is that you lose two thirds of the material,
so that if you have a rough stone weighing 9 carats, you should
finish up with a cut and polished stone weighing 3 carats, depending
on inclusions. This is considered the industry standard.
"I was
Chairman of the Work Force Committee which was part of an organisation
known as the Gemstone Working Party which looked at the training
systems and the possibilities of what could be implemented in Australia.
We put together a number of proposals based on the schools in Germany
which we feel could be adapted on a small scale within the Australian
industry. However, for an apprenticeship scheme to really work there
must be a couple of hundred people going through each year and at
this stage that does not seem feasible".
The type of
programme is reserved exclusively for handcutting, whereas the general
consensus within the industry lies in the future of automatic cutting
equipment, often involving hundreds of thousands of dollars in initial
investments.
"It is
possible to spend up to half a million dollars on the equipment
and in terms of having a large output - it really has enormous productivity
- if you were to set up properly, you could probably cut and polish
500-600 stones a day", says Brenton. "But there is still
a human element involved in that prior to the automated cutting
and polishing, there is a pre-shaping process that is all done by
hand where decisions are made by the operator as to colour and optimum
shape. Only then is the stone put on a 'dipstick' which enables
the cutter to hold it. An automatic cutter can hold thirty stones,
so all the stones go down together, all the facets are cut, then
removed and put in the polishing machine where the whole process
is repeated.
"The difficult
part at the moment is that all of the automatic cutting and polishing
equipment that is available overseas is generally used for much
cheaper quality gemstone material - semi - precious stones such
as topaz, blue amethyst and aquamarine. The trick is going to be
to use this equipment to maximise the yield in terms of the carat
weights because it really is quite a wasteful process. But this
seems to be the direction to pursue in terms of competing with labour
cots per cut and polished finished stone ex-Bangkok - this is the
issue that we have to come to grips with. I really think that this
is what the Australian industry has to strive to do in order to
compete with the Thai's"
Australian ability
and technical skill in the area have frequently come under critical
scrutiny and inspired a reluctance of dealers here to give Australian
cutters consistent work.
"Quite
often when I have given an Australian cutter sapphire to cut in
order to fill an order, the returned stone has been ruined",
says Gerry. "The standard of cutting here is in fact quite
high in that the cutter will work the stone and all the facets will
meet, the shape will be O.K., the depth will be fair but he still
can't bring out the natural colour, retain the maximum weight and
bring out the maximum brilliance. For instance, I gave a cutter
here a ten carat stone which was a perfect shape and excellent colour
for a ring. Because the shape was perfect, I expected 40% return,
but he returned 27% and when you are talking about top quality stones
like this, each point that is ground away is a lot of money wasted.
They just don't have the experience here whereas in Thailand, a
cutter may cut thousands of stones per year, although the cutting
is not 100% perfect in terms of how the facets are joined, they
still retain the colour and the brilliance of the stone. It is their
experience that enables them to get the maximum from the stone.
"Heat treating
is also another challenge for the Australian industry - the Thai's
have been doing it for many years now and certainly the base knowledge
of how to treat stones is well within the capabilities of Australian
science. The challenge which we face if we really want to further
advance the industry is to go beyond what is already being done
in terms of heat treatment". It is actually extremely difficult
to discern the natural stone from the heat treated sapphire although
some needles of rhutile will disappear once the stone has been heat
treated and made lighter. Depending on the stone, a dealer can usually
get 10-30% more for a natural stone".
It seems as
if the Australian sapphire industry is on the verge of an international
breakthrough - certainly it is well within its grasp. The deposits
in Kashmir are dwindling rapidly, Burma, Sri Lanka and the newly
sourced deposits in Africa suffer from a politically unstable climate
negating the motivation to invest heavily in mining in these areas.
China has been reported as housing sapphire deposits with similar
characteristics to the Australian but as yet no production has commenced.
And then there is Australia - for so long marked as inferior grade
quality and the kudos for the top quality attributed automatically
to other international sources. Her day has perhaps arrived.
"If a number
of the large producers here in Australia begin to take the initiative
to start cutting and polishing within the country, it is obviously
going to have an affect on t he gemstone market in Bangkok",
says Brenton. "Where the Thai's have been coming to Australia
and purchasing all of the rough and processing it in Bangkok, there
is of course going to be some impact if all of a sudden the supply
situation drops off.
"All in
all I think it is going to make the industry much more competitive
but we will have to weather a bit of a storm initially because when
processing begins on a large scale in Australia, many of the firms
will only want to deal in the top quality stones whereas the Thais
buy the entire package that the miner's have to offer. The Thais
will not want to purchase only the lower grade so there will be
a shakeout in the market but from my discussions with people in
Thailand in estimating the stockpiled Australian goods in Bangkok,
the consensus appears to be that if all the goods that had been
stored over years and years were cut and polished, there would only
be sufficient supply for one year's cutting and polishing. Unless
another major source is found very quickly, which is unforseeable
within the next 2-3 years, I think that the natural economics of
supply and demand will see the price of Australian sapphire increase
rapidly".
"After
keeping such a low profile for all these years, we are now going
to take a more active role to make sure that the same mistakes are
not made as in the past", says a confident Gerry. "The
future of the industry now lies in the hands of few people both
in the government and in the private sector. It is up to these few
people to guide and provide encouragement. Every day is a challenge
in this industry".
Motivate and
activate are the keys to success and with the bit firmly in the
mouths of young entrepreneurs prepared to realise long term goals
such as Gerry Yakoumelis, the precious stone that is gearing up
to launch an assault on the gemstone market is sapphire - Australian
sapphire.
|